Skip to content
5515 Cherokee Ave Suite 100, Alexandria, VA 22312
Call (703) 866-4224
Select Kitchen & Bath — home
Menu
  • Home
  • Projects
  • About
  • Cabinets
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • May 3, 2013

Comparing Kitchen Countertop Material Options

There are several considerations that a homeowner must entertain before they decide on a particular surface material for their new kitchen countertop. This surface may become the showpiece component of the new kitchen as well as being the most highly used surface in the home. Given the demands and popularity of the kitchen space, the countertop material is likely to become the most critical and difficult decision that a homeowner has to make with regards to their kitchen project. Let’s review some of the variables that need to be considered with the more popular and dominant countertop materials used in today’s kitchens: granite, quartz, marble/limestone/soapstone, solid surface, laminate, and concrete.

The Budget Variable

Generally speaking, the kitchen budget should allocate about one third (33%) of the total budget toward the cost associated with the countertop; and, more often than not, that figure can easily rise to roughly 40% of the gross budget, or more, if the homeowner builds the kitchen around the passionate desire for a particular countertop material. Obviously, a homeowner wants the best long-term value; and this is achieved by balancing the associated variables against the cost (per square foot) of the countertop material. One must also consider the transfer of value with respects to this countertop material being attractive to a new, prospective buyer of the home when it’s time to sell.

Among the most prevalent countertop materials used today, laminate surfaces are the least expensive option; and are attractive, serviceable, but tend not to score high in the transfer of value department. Following laminate, solid-surface materials become a logical bridge from laminate to stone and granite, (yet often overlapping the cost with some natural stones)l, looking and performing well while retaining most of their value in the transfer of value consideration. Beyond solid surface materials, the costs of the remainder of the group range, equal to or up to five times the cost, depending upon the rarity of the natural stone or the details and features added to the individual project. Suffice it to say that these surfaces constitute a considerable investment, so make sure you balance all your variables before making that final decision.

The ‘How I Live’ Variable

While most folks are, or can easily be swayed into, recognizing their budgetary issues with regards to a countertop material, these same folks are hesitant to examine their day-to-day living style and how it may influence their countertop decision. If you think about the child who gleefully asks, “Daddy, can we get a puppy–I promise to take care of him?”, then you’ll understand the point that’s being made here. Sometimes a desire for a particular material is not enough; and neither is the fact that you can afford it. Each countertop material has its inherent strengths, weaknesses and maintenance regimens. If the weaknesses and maintenance issues conflict with a household’s normal operations and challenges, then consider an alternate choice in material because it’s a lofty expectation (as with the puppy scenario) that a household will modify its normal behaviors just to accommodate the requirements of the new kitchen counter. So, do your homework on the shortcomings of each countertop material and be extremely honest in examining your normal living patterns before you settle on any material.

The Aesthetic Variable

Inasmuch as this variable is foremost on any countertop shopper’s mind, it doesn’t warrant a great deal of attention here. Everyone wants their new countertop to look good, perform beyond their expectations, and be the talking point of visiting friends and family. Such measures are a realistic goal and are achievable given the broad range of choices before you. You will find in laminate options, for example, that any conceivable coloration, texture, or pattern will be available to you. These options may emulate natural stone, tile or even a confetti look that will command attention in your eclectic kitchen. The smooth and flawless appeal of solid surface counters may provide the clarity and clean look you desire. Concrete is known for its design flexibility and can be worked to replicate a mass of stone, block of wood, or simply be an artist’s expression that ties everything together in your kitchen. Granite and quartz can render a stately look to a space that needs that bit of elegance, while never sacrificing the reality of the need of a durable, forgiving surface. Ceramic tile affords a sense of modularity whereby a variation of colors and textures can be utilized concurrently in order to balance-out the kitchen theme. Matte-polished limestone and soapstone constitute timeless looks of antiquity and function with a warming patina of naturally embellished stone luster. It’s a good idea to explore a number of different surfaces when putting your kitchen plans together; and you may discover that the countertop you initially intended to pursue just doesn’t have the overall aesthetic ‘pop’ that you were looking for in your new kitchen.

  • Share on Houzz
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Instagram
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Email
PrevPreviousThe ‘Crystal-Clear’ Trend in Virginia’s Kitchens
NextThe Functional Call of the Modern KitchenNext
More

Related Posts

A kitchen remodel done in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia by Select Kitchen & Bath.

Countertops

Designer insight Everything You Need to Know Before Picking Your Countertops When it comes to countertops, there’s a lot of details you should be thinking

Another Master bathroom remodel including a walk-in shower and custom niche.

Niches VS Shower Shelves

Shower Storage Practical Tips, Design Ideas and what to Consider When planning a shower remodel, one detail that often gets overlooked—but makes a big difference—is

Kitchen Remodel

You don’t always have to remove walls to renovate your kitchen

In this NE DC home, we expanded the kitchen into an adjacent space and reworked the layout. We added a beautiful apron sink, and extra

Recently remodeled kitchen in Reston, VA — Select Kitchen & Bath

Recently remodeled kitchen in Reston, Virginia

This two-tone kitchen features Crystal Cabinets: an alder wood island with Java finish surrounded by Simply White painted cabinetry. We were able to fit in

Beautiful and Breezy Master Bathroom Remodel in Manassas, VA

In this featured master bathroom remodel, the layout stayed largely the same, but the original vanity, tub and shower were replaced and upgraded! The shower

Remodeling awards & accreditations

We look forward to working with you!

NARI member for 15 years — Select Kitchen & Bath remodeler profile
NKBA Certified Member — National Kitchen & Bath Association, Select Kitchen & Bath
EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm — Select Kitchen & Bath
Better Business Bureau A+ rated — Select Kitchen & Bath BBB profile
2025 Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite — Select Kitchen & Bath on Nextdoor
Best of Houzz Service 2026 award — Select Kitchen & Bath on Houzz
Angi 2020 award — Select Kitchen & Bath reviews on Angi
Contact Us
Select Kitchen & Bath — home

Navigation

  • Home
  • Projects
  • About
  • Cabinets
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy

Get In Touch

  • 5515 Cherokee Avenue,
    Suite 100
    Alexandria, VA 22312
  • (703) 866-4224
  • info@selectkitchenandbath.com
  • Monday - Friday
  • 08:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Copyright © 2026 Select Kitchen & Bath. All Rights Reserved. Site by Girl Tech Mafia.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Houzz
  • Share on Houzz
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Instagram
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Email